Current Conditions
27 ° Cloudy

Springville Journal editorial: Who’s paying for your Cheerios®?

By now, New York’s taxpayers have grown accustomed to having slices of their already-lean paychecks shaved off, to accommodate the needs – or wants – of the rest of the population. There is nothing we can do, to oppose the bleeding of our incomes, so we silently watch the “withholding” column on our paychecks grow and cross our fingers that the people who are getting the rest of our earnings actually need the government assistance we’ve worked so hard to provide them with.

Unfortunately, as with most superstitions, the finger-crossing has been unsuccessful. Three different press releases about Welfare abuse – most specifically, food stamp fraud – crossed my desk, this week.

A separate article could be written about the inaccuracy in New York’s Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (for a scary reality check, read “Worst Foods Available with Food Stamps” on, but I will readily admit that many people in our state truly need help, to provide for themselves and their families. Many do utilize those resources in a wise and economical manner.

Unfortunately, they are not the only people snagging the government’s handouts.

Three, separate individuals from Cattaraugus County were recently arrested for essentially stealing food from the government, by using SNAP benefit cards that did not belong to them. The amount of money they scammed, in food, before they were caught, ranged from $84 – $313. Guess whose pockets that money came from?

To my horror, the stories got worse. As I read these releases more closely, I discovered that all of the misused benefit cards belonged to inmates who are currently residing in the Cattaraugus County Jail.

According to CBS News, it costs taxpayers between $50,000 – $60,000, to house an inmate for a year. Those expenses include security, medical care, psychiatric services, pharmaceuticals, dental care, facility operations, maintenance of inmate records, transportation, activities, employment, clothing, religious activities, education, vocational training and substance abuse programs. Also, food.

So, why are inmates receiving food stamp assistance? The argument that those cards are required by the cardholders’ families should be negated by the fact that these inmates chose to break the law. If food stamps are truly needed by those individuals, another family member should apply for them.

Our government has long turned a blind eye to the misuse of its assistance programs, but many taxpayers are beginning to sit up and take notice.

As New York slumps at the bottom of the economic totem poll, it cannot afford to be bleeding money and forcing its taxpayers to leave the state, because their incomes no longer cover their own expenses, much less others’.

More checks and balances need to be instituted, for people who are receiving help, from the rest of us. Despite the protests that I know have ensued, individuals receiving government assistance should be required to do some form of work, be illegal drug-free and be subjected to regular checks on their assistance usage.

People abusing the system need to be stopped, so citizens who truly need help can receive the benefits they require.

The Erie County Department of Social Services’ Special Investigations Division is asking for the community’s help, to prevent people from receiving benefits or payments that they are not entitled to.

If you become aware of a benefit fraud situation, contact the division, via its telephone hotline, at 858-1886; email or write to the ECDSS Special Education Division, 95 Franklin St., Buffalo, NY 14202.

You must be signed in to comment.

Click Here to create a Free Account

Click here to Sign in


2013-04-11 | 10:58:03
So to the already high costs, you want to add the cost of possibly thousands of new state employees to administer all of these added requirements. The cost of the drug tests (weekly? monthly?) to show that the people are drug free. Someone to follow them around while they do the "make work" that benefits no one. And on top of that, you'll pay someone to go through the store records to be sure they didn't buy their kids any potato chips! Well, I am a LOT less than enthusiastic about your plans for further waste of money.